Neale, Miles (2014). No rest for the wicked; no leisure for the poor: A comparison of Japanese and English proverbs using Natural Semantic Metalanguage. BA(Hons) thesis, University of Queensland.
Abstract:
Can two proverbs created by different cultures in different languages have the same meaning? This dissertation presents the results of an investigation comparing the core meanings of ten Japanese and English proverbs that certain proverb dictionaries define as being equivalent in meaning. The thesis compares Japanese proverbs chosen from iroha karuta, a proverb-based card game, with English ‘equivalents’ listed in Japanese proverb dictionaries. The investigation uses data from the Balanced Corpus of Contemporary Written Japanese, the British National Corpus and a corpus of internet blogs to develop semantic explications that demonstrate the core meaning of each proverb. These explications reveal that many of the Japanese proverbs rely on a different metaphor, offer different advice and index a different real-world situation compared to their English ‘equivalents’. The results of this investigation demonstrate how proverbs reproduce folk wisdom, ritual and the differing ideologies of Japanese and English culture.
More information:
The following proverbs are explicated and compared:
Nen niwa nen o ireyo versus Look before you leap
Binbō hima nashi versus No rest for the wicked
Inu mo arukeba bō ni ataru versus Every dog has its day
Ryōyaku wa kuchi ni nigashi versus Good medicine tastes bitter
Ron yori shōko versus The proof of the pudding is in the eating
Nakittsura ni hachi versus To pour salt on the wound
Atama kakushite shiri kakusazu versus The foolish ostrich buries its head in the sand (and thinks it is not seen)
Chiri mo tsumoreba yama to naru versus Many a little makes a mickle
Hana yori dango versus Pudding before praise
Raku areba ku ari versus There is no pleasure without pain
Rating:
Sound application of NSM principles carried out without prior training by an experienced NSM practitioner
